Spreads & Nut Butters Food Quality Guide
Spreads and nut butters are compared on protein, fat quality, sugar and sodium alongside ingredient simplicity. A product with minimal ingredients may still score lower on Longevity if saturated fat or sodium is high for the serving size. This page summarizes 16 published spreads & nut butters products currently analyzed by Food Quality Guide, with links to each individual breakdown.
Category summary
- Spreads & Nut Butters products analyzed
- 16
- Scored on both measures
- 16
- Median Longevity Score
- 90/100
- Median Food Integrity Score
- 88/100
- Scoring 80+ on both
- 9
- Brands represented
- 3
- 16 spreads & nut butters products analyzed with both Longevity and Food Integrity scores.
- 9 score at least 80 on both measures.
- Highest Longevity Score in this category: 100/100 (Trader Joe's Avocado's Number Guacamole To Go).
- Highest Food Integrity Score in this category: 96/100 (Trader Joe's Avocado's Number Guacamole To Go).
- Median scores across analyzed spreads & nut butters products: Longevity 90/100, Food Integrity 88/100.
- 3 brands represented in this category page.
How the two scores differ
- Longevity Score
- Evaluates nutrition-related characteristics relevant to longer-term eating patterns. Longevity methodology
- Food Integrity Score
- Evaluates ingredient composition, processing and related ingredient-quality considerations. Food Integrity methodology
Food Integrity examines characteristics such as ingredients, processing and additive concerns, while Longevity evaluates nutrition-related characteristics associated with longer-term eating patterns. Because the two analyses answer different questions, a product can perform differently under each.
Highest Longevity Scores in Spreads & Nut Butters
Ranked by Longevity Score, then Food Integrity Score, then product name.
- Rank 1

Avocado's Number Guacamole To Go
Exceptional Choice
- Longevity Score
- 100/100
- Food Integrity Score
- 96/100
Longevity analysis for Trader Joe's Avocado's Number Guacamole To GoFood Integrity analysis for Trader Joe's Avocado's Number Guacamole To Go
- Rank 2

Organic Creamy Peanut Butter
Exceptional Choice
- Longevity Score
- 98/100
- Food Integrity Score
- 95/100
Longevity analysis for Kirkland Signature Organic Creamy Peanut ButterFood Integrity analysis for Kirkland Signature Organic Creamy Peanut Butter
- Rank 3

Almond Butter
Exceptional Choice
- Longevity Score
- 95/100
- Food Integrity Score
- 95/100
Longevity analysis for Trader Joe's Almond ButterFood Integrity analysis for Trader Joe's Almond Butter
- Rank 4

Dukkah
Exceptional Choice
- Longevity Score
- 95/100
- Food Integrity Score
- 95/100
Longevity analysis for Trader Joe's DukkahFood Integrity analysis for Trader Joe's Dukkah
- Rank 5

Guacasalsa
Exceptional Choice
- Longevity Score
- 95/100
- Food Integrity Score
- 95/100
Longevity analysis for Trader Joe's GuacasalsaFood Integrity analysis for Trader Joe's Guacasalsa
- Rank 6

Organic Chunky Homestyle Guacamole
Exceptional Choice
- Longevity Score
- 95/100
- Food Integrity Score
- 95/100
Longevity analysis for Trader Joe's Organic Chunky Homestyle GuacamoleFood Integrity analysis for Trader Joe's Organic Chunky Homestyle Guacamole
- Rank 7

Fiesta Guacamole
Exceptional Choice
- Longevity Score
- 95/100
- Food Integrity Score
- 93/100
Longevity analysis for Trader Joe's Fiesta GuacamoleFood Integrity analysis for Trader Joe's Fiesta Guacamole
- Rank 8

Olive Tapenade Hummus
Solid Choice
- Longevity Score
- 92/100
- Food Integrity Score
- 79/100
Longevity analysis for Trader Joe's Olive Tapenade HummusFood Integrity analysis for Trader Joe's Olive Tapenade Hummus
- Rank 9

Tabbouleh Style Hummus
Solid Choice
- Longevity Score
- 88/100
- Food Integrity Score
- 82/100
Longevity analysis for Trader Joe's Tabbouleh Style HummusFood Integrity analysis for Trader Joe's Tabbouleh Style Hummus
- Rank 10

Peanut Butter With Honey
Exceptional Choice
- Longevity Score
- 85/100
- Food Integrity Score
- 93/100
Longevity analysis for Trader Joe's Peanut Butter With HoneyFood Integrity analysis for Trader Joe's Peanut Butter With Honey
Highest Food Integrity Scores in Spreads & Nut Butters
Ranked by Food Integrity Score, then Longevity Score, then product name.
- Rank 1

Avocado's Number Guacamole To Go
Exceptional Choice
- Longevity Score
- 100/100
- Food Integrity Score
- 96/100
Longevity analysis for Trader Joe's Avocado's Number Guacamole To GoFood Integrity analysis for Trader Joe's Avocado's Number Guacamole To Go
- Rank 2

Organic Creamy Peanut Butter
Exceptional Choice
- Longevity Score
- 98/100
- Food Integrity Score
- 95/100
Longevity analysis for Kirkland Signature Organic Creamy Peanut ButterFood Integrity analysis for Kirkland Signature Organic Creamy Peanut Butter
- Rank 3

Almond Butter
Exceptional Choice
- Longevity Score
- 95/100
- Food Integrity Score
- 95/100
Longevity analysis for Trader Joe's Almond ButterFood Integrity analysis for Trader Joe's Almond Butter
- Rank 4

Dukkah
Exceptional Choice
- Longevity Score
- 95/100
- Food Integrity Score
- 95/100
Longevity analysis for Trader Joe's DukkahFood Integrity analysis for Trader Joe's Dukkah
- Rank 5

Guacasalsa
Exceptional Choice
- Longevity Score
- 95/100
- Food Integrity Score
- 95/100
Longevity analysis for Trader Joe's GuacasalsaFood Integrity analysis for Trader Joe's Guacasalsa
- Rank 6

Organic Chunky Homestyle Guacamole
Exceptional Choice
- Longevity Score
- 95/100
- Food Integrity Score
- 95/100
Longevity analysis for Trader Joe's Organic Chunky Homestyle GuacamoleFood Integrity analysis for Trader Joe's Organic Chunky Homestyle Guacamole
- Rank 7

Fiesta Guacamole
Exceptional Choice
- Longevity Score
- 95/100
- Food Integrity Score
- 93/100
Longevity analysis for Trader Joe's Fiesta GuacamoleFood Integrity analysis for Trader Joe's Fiesta Guacamole
- Rank 8

Peanut Butter With Honey
Exceptional Choice
- Longevity Score
- 85/100
- Food Integrity Score
- 93/100
Longevity analysis for Trader Joe's Peanut Butter With HoneyFood Integrity analysis for Trader Joe's Peanut Butter With Honey
- Rank 9

Tabbouleh Style Hummus
Solid Choice
- Longevity Score
- 88/100
- Food Integrity Score
- 82/100
Longevity analysis for Trader Joe's Tabbouleh Style HummusFood Integrity analysis for Trader Joe's Tabbouleh Style Hummus
- Rank 10

Olive Tapenade Hummus
Solid Choice
- Longevity Score
- 92/100
- Food Integrity Score
- 79/100
Longevity analysis for Trader Joe's Olive Tapenade HummusFood Integrity analysis for Trader Joe's Olive Tapenade Hummus
Strong Spreads & Nut Butters Products Across Both Scores
Ranked by the weaker of the two scores.
Products in this section perform strongly under both Food Quality Guide scoring lenses; ranking favors the weaker of the two scores so a very high result in one dimension does not conceal a substantially lower result in the other.
- Rank 1

Avocado's Number Guacamole To Go
Exceptional Choice
- Longevity Score
- 100/100
- Food Integrity Score
- 96/100
Longevity analysis for Trader Joe's Avocado's Number Guacamole To GoFood Integrity analysis for Trader Joe's Avocado's Number Guacamole To Go
- Rank 2

Organic Creamy Peanut Butter
Exceptional Choice
- Longevity Score
- 98/100
- Food Integrity Score
- 95/100
Longevity analysis for Kirkland Signature Organic Creamy Peanut ButterFood Integrity analysis for Kirkland Signature Organic Creamy Peanut Butter
- Rank 3

Almond Butter
Exceptional Choice
- Longevity Score
- 95/100
- Food Integrity Score
- 95/100
Longevity analysis for Trader Joe's Almond ButterFood Integrity analysis for Trader Joe's Almond Butter
- Rank 4

Dukkah
Exceptional Choice
- Longevity Score
- 95/100
- Food Integrity Score
- 95/100
Longevity analysis for Trader Joe's DukkahFood Integrity analysis for Trader Joe's Dukkah
- Rank 5

Guacasalsa
Exceptional Choice
- Longevity Score
- 95/100
- Food Integrity Score
- 95/100
Longevity analysis for Trader Joe's GuacasalsaFood Integrity analysis for Trader Joe's Guacasalsa
- Rank 6

Organic Chunky Homestyle Guacamole
Exceptional Choice
- Longevity Score
- 95/100
- Food Integrity Score
- 95/100
Longevity analysis for Trader Joe's Organic Chunky Homestyle GuacamoleFood Integrity analysis for Trader Joe's Organic Chunky Homestyle Guacamole
- Rank 7

Fiesta Guacamole
Exceptional Choice
- Longevity Score
- 95/100
- Food Integrity Score
- 93/100
Longevity analysis for Trader Joe's Fiesta GuacamoleFood Integrity analysis for Trader Joe's Fiesta Guacamole
- Rank 8

Peanut Butter With Honey
Exceptional Choice
- Longevity Score
- 85/100
- Food Integrity Score
- 93/100
Longevity analysis for Trader Joe's Peanut Butter With HoneyFood Integrity analysis for Trader Joe's Peanut Butter With Honey
- Rank 9

Tabbouleh Style Hummus
Solid Choice
- Longevity Score
- 88/100
- Food Integrity Score
- 82/100
Longevity analysis for Trader Joe's Tabbouleh Style HummusFood Integrity analysis for Trader Joe's Tabbouleh Style Hummus
- Rank 10

Olive Tapenade Hummus
Solid Choice
- Longevity Score
- 92/100
- Food Integrity Score
- 79/100
Longevity analysis for Trader Joe's Olive Tapenade HummusFood Integrity analysis for Trader Joe's Olive Tapenade Hummus
All analyzed Spreads & Nut Butters products
16 analyzed products, ranked by balanced score (weaker of Longevity and Food Integrity scores).
- Avocado's Number Guacamole To GoLongevity Score 100/100 · Food Integrity Score 96/100Longevity analysis for Trader Joe's Avocado's Number Guacamole To Go · Food Integrity analysis for Trader Joe's Avocado's Number Guacamole To Go
- Organic Creamy Peanut ButterLongevity Score 98/100 · Food Integrity Score 95/100Longevity analysis for Kirkland Signature Organic Creamy Peanut Butter · Food Integrity analysis for Kirkland Signature Organic Creamy Peanut Butter
- Almond ButterLongevity Score 95/100 · Food Integrity Score 95/100Longevity analysis for Trader Joe's Almond Butter · Food Integrity analysis for Trader Joe's Almond Butter
- DukkahLongevity Score 95/100 · Food Integrity Score 95/100Longevity analysis for Trader Joe's Dukkah · Food Integrity analysis for Trader Joe's Dukkah
- GuacasalsaLongevity Score 95/100 · Food Integrity Score 95/100Longevity analysis for Trader Joe's Guacasalsa · Food Integrity analysis for Trader Joe's Guacasalsa
- Organic Chunky Homestyle GuacamoleLongevity Score 95/100 · Food Integrity Score 95/100Longevity analysis for Trader Joe's Organic Chunky Homestyle Guacamole · Food Integrity analysis for Trader Joe's Organic Chunky Homestyle Guacamole
- Fiesta GuacamoleLongevity Score 95/100 · Food Integrity Score 93/100Longevity analysis for Trader Joe's Fiesta Guacamole · Food Integrity analysis for Trader Joe's Fiesta Guacamole
- Peanut Butter With HoneyLongevity Score 85/100 · Food Integrity Score 93/100Longevity analysis for Trader Joe's Peanut Butter With Honey · Food Integrity analysis for Trader Joe's Peanut Butter With Honey
- Tabbouleh Style HummusLongevity Score 88/100 · Food Integrity Score 82/100Longevity analysis for Trader Joe's Tabbouleh Style Hummus · Food Integrity analysis for Trader Joe's Tabbouleh Style Hummus
- Olive Tapenade HummusLongevity Score 92/100 · Food Integrity Score 79/100Longevity analysis for Trader Joe's Olive Tapenade Hummus · Food Integrity analysis for Trader Joe's Olive Tapenade Hummus
- Spreadable Butter With Canola Oil, Canola OilLongevity Score 70/100 · Food Integrity Score 71/100Longevity analysis for Great Value Spreadable Butter With Canola Oil, Canola Oil · Food Integrity analysis for Great Value Spreadable Butter With Canola Oil, Canola Oil
- Organic Buttery Plant-Based SpreadLongevity Score 70/100 · Food Integrity Score 67/100Longevity analysis for Trader Joe's Organic Buttery Plant-Based Spread · Food Integrity analysis for Trader Joe's Organic Buttery Plant-Based Spread
- Roasted Red Pepper Seasoned Butter, Roasted Red PepperLongevity Score 65/100 · Food Integrity Score 70/100Longevity analysis for Great Value Roasted Red Pepper Seasoned Butter, Roasted Red Pepper · Food Integrity analysis for Great Value Roasted Red Pepper Seasoned Butter, Roasted Red Pepper
- Vegan Buttery SpreadLongevity Score 65/100 · Food Integrity Score 62/100Longevity analysis for Trader Joe's Vegan Buttery Spread · Food Integrity analysis for Trader Joe's Vegan Buttery Spread
- Creamy Peanut Butter, CreamyLongevity Score 80/100 · Food Integrity Score 55/100Longevity analysis for Great Value Creamy Peanut Butter, Creamy · Food Integrity analysis for Great Value Creamy Peanut Butter, Creamy
- Cocoa Almond SpreadLongevity Score 40/100 · Food Integrity Score 53/100Longevity analysis for Trader Joe's Cocoa Almond Spread · Food Integrity analysis for Trader Joe's Cocoa Almond Spread
