Private Selection Healthy Food Guide

Explore Healthy Food Guide's analysis of 19 published Private Selection products, comparing Longevity and Food Integrity scores side by side. Rankings are calculated from the same scoring methods used on each individual product analysis, and every entry links to the underlying breakdown. This page covers the Private Selection products currently analyzed and published by Healthy Food Guide, not the full store catalog.

Dataset summary

Private Selection products published: 24
Scored on both measures: 19
Median Longevity Score: 62/100
Median Food Integrity Score: 84/100
Scoring 80+ on both: 4
Categories covered: 8

Highest Longevity Score among the 19 currently analyzed Private Selection products: Private Selection Hearts Of Palm In Brine — 93/100.
Highest Food Integrity Score: Private Selection Hearts Of Palm In Brine — 92/100.
4 of 19 analyzed products score at least 80 on both measures.
Median scores across the analyzed set: Longevity 62/100, Food Integrity 84/100.

How the two scores differ

Longevity Score: Evaluates nutrition-related characteristics relevant to longer-term eating patterns. Longevity methodology
Food Integrity Score: Evaluates ingredient composition, processing and related ingredient-quality considerations. Food Integrity methodology

Food Integrity examines characteristics such as ingredients, processing and additive concerns, while Longevity evaluates nutrition-related characteristics associated with longer-term eating patterns. Because the two analyses answer different questions, a product can perform differently under each.

Highest Longevity Scores

Ranked by Longevity Score, then Food Integrity Score, then product name.

Rank 1
Private Selection Hearts Of Palm In Brine
Pantry & Oils
Exceptional Choice
Longevity Score
93/100
Food Integrity Score
92/100
Longevity analysis for Private Selection Hearts Of Palm In Brine Food Integrity analysis for Private Selection Hearts Of Palm In Brine
Rank 2
Private Selection Wild Caught Mackerel Fillets In Extra Virgin Olive Oil
Seafood
Exceptional Choice
Longevity Score
92/100
Food Integrity Score
92/100
Longevity analysis for Private Selection Wild Caught Mackerel Fillets In Extra Virgin Olive Oil Food Integrity analysis for Private Selection Wild Caught Mackerel Fillets In Extra Virgin Olive Oil
Rank 3
Private Selection Cracked Pepper Hot Smoked Norwegian Atlantic Salmon
Seafood
Exceptional Choice
Longevity Score
88/100
Food Integrity Score
88/100
Longevity analysis for Private Selection Cracked Pepper Hot Smoked Norwegian Atlantic Salmon Food Integrity analysis for Private Selection Cracked Pepper Hot Smoked Norwegian Atlantic Salmon
Rank 4
Private Selection Succulent & Rich Peeled & Deveined Cooked Giant Tiger Prawns
Seafood
Solid Choice
Longevity Score
88/100
Food Integrity Score
84/100
Longevity analysis for Private Selection Succulent & Rich Peeled & Deveined Cooked Giant Tiger Prawns Food Integrity analysis for Private Selection Succulent & Rich Peeled & Deveined Cooked Giant Tiger Prawns
Rank 5
Private Selection Pepper Jack Sliced Cheese
Dairy
Solid Choice
Longevity Score
78/100
Food Integrity Score
92/100
Longevity analysis for Private Selection Pepper Jack Sliced Cheese Food Integrity analysis for Private Selection Pepper Jack Sliced Cheese
Rank 6
Private Selection Dark 62% Cacao Chocolate Chunks
Sweets & Desserts
Enjoy in Moderation
Longevity Score
78/100
Food Integrity Score
84/100
Longevity analysis for Private Selection Dark 62% Cacao Chocolate Chunks Food Integrity analysis for Private Selection Dark 62% Cacao Chocolate Chunks
Rank 7
Private Selection Colby Jack Sliced Cheese
Dairy
Solid Choice
Longevity Score
72/100
Food Integrity Score
88/100
Longevity analysis for Private Selection Colby Jack Sliced Cheese Food Integrity analysis for Private Selection Colby Jack Sliced Cheese
Rank 8
Private Selection Peppercorn & Poppy Water Crisps
Snacks
Enjoy in Moderation
Longevity Score
72/100
Food Integrity Score
78/100
Longevity analysis for Private Selection Peppercorn & Poppy Water Crisps Food Integrity analysis for Private Selection Peppercorn & Poppy Water Crisps
Rank 9
Private Selection Colby Jack Cheese Cubes
Dairy
Choose Occasionally
Longevity Score
62/100
Food Integrity Score
88/100
Longevity analysis for Private Selection Colby Jack Cheese Cubes Food Integrity analysis for Private Selection Colby Jack Cheese Cubes
Rank 10
Private Selection Mild Cheddar Blend Thick Cut Shredded Cheese
Dairy
Choose Occasionally
Longevity Score
62/100
Food Integrity Score
84/100
Longevity analysis for Private Selection Mild Cheddar Blend Thick Cut Shredded Cheese Food Integrity analysis for Private Selection Mild Cheddar Blend Thick Cut Shredded Cheese

Highest Food Integrity Scores

Ranked by Food Integrity Score, then Longevity Score, then product name.

Rank 1
Private Selection Hearts Of Palm In Brine
Pantry & Oils
Exceptional Choice
Longevity Score
93/100
Food Integrity Score
92/100
Longevity analysis for Private Selection Hearts Of Palm In Brine Food Integrity analysis for Private Selection Hearts Of Palm In Brine
Rank 2
Private Selection Wild Caught Mackerel Fillets In Extra Virgin Olive Oil
Seafood
Exceptional Choice
Longevity Score
92/100
Food Integrity Score
92/100
Longevity analysis for Private Selection Wild Caught Mackerel Fillets In Extra Virgin Olive Oil Food Integrity analysis for Private Selection Wild Caught Mackerel Fillets In Extra Virgin Olive Oil
Rank 3
Private Selection Pepper Jack Sliced Cheese
Dairy
Solid Choice
Longevity Score
78/100
Food Integrity Score
92/100
Longevity analysis for Private Selection Pepper Jack Sliced Cheese Food Integrity analysis for Private Selection Pepper Jack Sliced Cheese
Rank 4
Private Selection Cracked Pepper Hot Smoked Norwegian Atlantic Salmon
Seafood
Exceptional Choice
Longevity Score
88/100
Food Integrity Score
88/100
Longevity analysis for Private Selection Cracked Pepper Hot Smoked Norwegian Atlantic Salmon Food Integrity analysis for Private Selection Cracked Pepper Hot Smoked Norwegian Atlantic Salmon
Rank 5
Private Selection Colby Jack Sliced Cheese
Dairy
Solid Choice
Longevity Score
72/100
Food Integrity Score
88/100
Longevity analysis for Private Selection Colby Jack Sliced Cheese Food Integrity analysis for Private Selection Colby Jack Sliced Cheese
Rank 6
Private Selection Colby Jack Cheese Cubes
Dairy
Choose Occasionally
Longevity Score
62/100
Food Integrity Score
88/100
Longevity analysis for Private Selection Colby Jack Cheese Cubes Food Integrity analysis for Private Selection Colby Jack Cheese Cubes
Rank 7
Private Selection Succulent & Rich Peeled & Deveined Cooked Giant Tiger Prawns
Seafood
Solid Choice
Longevity Score
88/100
Food Integrity Score
84/100
Longevity analysis for Private Selection Succulent & Rich Peeled & Deveined Cooked Giant Tiger Prawns Food Integrity analysis for Private Selection Succulent & Rich Peeled & Deveined Cooked Giant Tiger Prawns
Rank 8
Private Selection Dark 62% Cacao Chocolate Chunks
Sweets & Desserts
Enjoy in Moderation
Longevity Score
78/100
Food Integrity Score
84/100
Longevity analysis for Private Selection Dark 62% Cacao Chocolate Chunks Food Integrity analysis for Private Selection Dark 62% Cacao Chocolate Chunks
Rank 9
Private Selection Mild Cheddar Blend Thick Cut Shredded Cheese
Dairy
Choose Occasionally
Longevity Score
62/100
Food Integrity Score
84/100
Longevity analysis for Private Selection Mild Cheddar Blend Thick Cut Shredded Cheese Food Integrity analysis for Private Selection Mild Cheddar Blend Thick Cut Shredded Cheese
Rank 10
Private Selection Black Cherry Sorbet
Ice Cream & Frozen Desserts
Limit When Possible
Longevity Score
42/100
Food Integrity Score
84/100
Longevity analysis for Private Selection Black Cherry Sorbet Food Integrity analysis for Private Selection Black Cherry Sorbet

Strong Across Both Scores

Ranked by the weaker of the two scores.

Products in this section perform strongly under both Healthy Food Guide scoring lenses; ranking favors the weaker of the two scores so a very high result in one dimension does not conceal a substantially lower result in the other.

Rank 1
Private Selection Hearts Of Palm In Brine
Pantry & Oils
Exceptional Choice
Longevity Score
93/100
Food Integrity Score
92/100
Longevity analysis for Private Selection Hearts Of Palm In Brine Food Integrity analysis for Private Selection Hearts Of Palm In Brine
Rank 2
Private Selection Wild Caught Mackerel Fillets In Extra Virgin Olive Oil
Seafood
Exceptional Choice
Longevity Score
92/100
Food Integrity Score
92/100
Longevity analysis for Private Selection Wild Caught Mackerel Fillets In Extra Virgin Olive Oil Food Integrity analysis for Private Selection Wild Caught Mackerel Fillets In Extra Virgin Olive Oil
Rank 3
Private Selection Cracked Pepper Hot Smoked Norwegian Atlantic Salmon
Seafood
Exceptional Choice
Longevity Score
88/100
Food Integrity Score
88/100
Longevity analysis for Private Selection Cracked Pepper Hot Smoked Norwegian Atlantic Salmon Food Integrity analysis for Private Selection Cracked Pepper Hot Smoked Norwegian Atlantic Salmon
Rank 4
Private Selection Succulent & Rich Peeled & Deveined Cooked Giant Tiger Prawns
Seafood
Solid Choice
Longevity Score
88/100
Food Integrity Score
84/100
Longevity analysis for Private Selection Succulent & Rich Peeled & Deveined Cooked Giant Tiger Prawns Food Integrity analysis for Private Selection Succulent & Rich Peeled & Deveined Cooked Giant Tiger Prawns
Rank 5
Private Selection Pepper Jack Sliced Cheese
Dairy
Solid Choice
Longevity Score
78/100
Food Integrity Score
92/100
Longevity analysis for Private Selection Pepper Jack Sliced Cheese Food Integrity analysis for Private Selection Pepper Jack Sliced Cheese
Rank 6
Private Selection Dark 62% Cacao Chocolate Chunks
Sweets & Desserts
Enjoy in Moderation
Longevity Score
78/100
Food Integrity Score
84/100
Longevity analysis for Private Selection Dark 62% Cacao Chocolate Chunks Food Integrity analysis for Private Selection Dark 62% Cacao Chocolate Chunks
Rank 7
Private Selection Colby Jack Sliced Cheese
Dairy
Solid Choice
Longevity Score
72/100
Food Integrity Score
88/100
Longevity analysis for Private Selection Colby Jack Sliced Cheese Food Integrity analysis for Private Selection Colby Jack Sliced Cheese
Rank 8
Private Selection Peppercorn & Poppy Water Crisps
Snacks
Enjoy in Moderation
Longevity Score
72/100
Food Integrity Score
78/100
Longevity analysis for Private Selection Peppercorn & Poppy Water Crisps Food Integrity analysis for Private Selection Peppercorn & Poppy Water Crisps
Rank 9
Private Selection Colby Jack Cheese Cubes
Dairy
Choose Occasionally
Longevity Score
62/100
Food Integrity Score
88/100
Longevity analysis for Private Selection Colby Jack Cheese Cubes Food Integrity analysis for Private Selection Colby Jack Cheese Cubes
Rank 10
Private Selection Mild Cheddar Blend Thick Cut Shredded Cheese
Dairy
Choose Occasionally
Longevity Score
62/100
Food Integrity Score
84/100
Longevity analysis for Private Selection Mild Cheddar Blend Thick Cut Shredded Cheese Food Integrity analysis for Private Selection Mild Cheddar Blend Thick Cut Shredded Cheese

Where Longevity and Food Integrity Differ

Ranked by the size of the gap between the two scores.

Longevity and Food Integrity measure different characteristics, so some foods can score very differently depending on whether nutrition patterns or ingredient and processing characteristics are emphasized. Neither score is the correct one — they answer different questions.

Rank 1
Private Selection White Chocolate Chips
Sweets & Desserts
Consider Avoiding
Longevity Score
22/100
Food Integrity Score
84/100
Score difference
62 points
Longevity analysis for Private Selection White Chocolate Chips Food Integrity analysis for Private Selection White Chocolate Chips
Rank 2
Private Selection Black Cherry Sorbet
Ice Cream & Frozen Desserts
Limit When Possible
Longevity Score
42/100
Food Integrity Score
84/100
Score difference
42 points
Longevity analysis for Private Selection Black Cherry Sorbet Food Integrity analysis for Private Selection Black Cherry Sorbet
Rank 3
Private Selection Colby Jack Cheese Cubes
Dairy
Choose Occasionally
Longevity Score
62/100
Food Integrity Score
88/100
Score difference
26 points
Longevity analysis for Private Selection Colby Jack Cheese Cubes Food Integrity analysis for Private Selection Colby Jack Cheese Cubes
Rank 4
Private Selection Milk Chocolate Sea Salt Caramels
Sweets & Desserts
Consider Avoiding
Longevity Score
28/100
Food Integrity Score
52/100
Score difference
24 points
Longevity analysis for Private Selection Milk Chocolate Sea Salt Caramels Food Integrity analysis for Private Selection Milk Chocolate Sea Salt Caramels
Rank 5
Private Selection Mild Cheddar Blend Thick Cut Shredded Cheese
Dairy
Choose Occasionally
Longevity Score
62/100
Food Integrity Score
84/100
Score difference
22 points
Longevity analysis for Private Selection Mild Cheddar Blend Thick Cut Shredded Cheese Food Integrity analysis for Private Selection Mild Cheddar Blend Thick Cut Shredded Cheese
Rank 6
Private Selection Smokehouse Deli Sliced Off The Bone Ham
Meat & Poultry
Limit When Possible
Longevity Score
42/100
Food Integrity Score
62/100
Score difference
20 points
Longevity analysis for Private Selection Smokehouse Deli Sliced Off The Bone Ham Food Integrity analysis for Private Selection Smokehouse Deli Sliced Off The Bone Ham
Rank 7
Private Selection Smoked Gouda Cheese Shreds
Dairy
Choose Occasionally
Longevity Score
62/100
Food Integrity Score
80/100
Score difference
18 points
Longevity analysis for Private Selection Smoked Gouda Cheese Shreds Food Integrity analysis for Private Selection Smoked Gouda Cheese Shreds
Rank 8
Private Selection Colby Jack Sliced Cheese
Dairy
Solid Choice
Longevity Score
72/100
Food Integrity Score
88/100
Score difference
16 points
Longevity analysis for Private Selection Colby Jack Sliced Cheese Food Integrity analysis for Private Selection Colby Jack Sliced Cheese

Leading Private Selection products at a glance

10 leading Private Selection products, ordered so the weaker of the two scores leads.
Product	Longevity Score	Food Integrity Score	Category
Private Selection Hearts Of Palm In Brine	93/100	92/100	Pantry & Oils
Private Selection Wild Caught Mackerel Fillets In Extra Virgin Olive Oil	92/100	92/100	Seafood
Private Selection Cracked Pepper Hot Smoked Norwegian Atlantic Salmon	88/100	88/100	Seafood
Private Selection Succulent & Rich Peeled & Deveined Cooked Giant Tiger Prawns	88/100	84/100	Seafood
Private Selection Pepper Jack Sliced Cheese	78/100	92/100	Dairy
Private Selection Dark 62% Cacao Chocolate Chunks	78/100	84/100	Sweets & Desserts
Private Selection Colby Jack Sliced Cheese	72/100	88/100	Dairy
Private Selection Peppercorn & Poppy Water Crisps	72/100	78/100	Snacks
Private Selection Colby Jack Cheese Cubes	62/100	88/100	Dairy
Private Selection Mild Cheddar Blend Thick Cut Shredded Cheese	62/100	84/100	Dairy

Private Selection highlights by category

Categories with enough analyzed products to compare. Ordering favors the weaker of the two scores.

Dairy (6 analyzed)

Rank 1
Private Selection Pepper Jack Sliced Cheese
Dairy
Solid Choice
Longevity Score
78/100
Food Integrity Score
92/100
Longevity analysis for Private Selection Pepper Jack Sliced Cheese Food Integrity analysis for Private Selection Pepper Jack Sliced Cheese
Rank 2
Private Selection Colby Jack Sliced Cheese
Dairy
Solid Choice
Longevity Score
72/100
Food Integrity Score
88/100
Longevity analysis for Private Selection Colby Jack Sliced Cheese Food Integrity analysis for Private Selection Colby Jack Sliced Cheese
Rank 3
Private Selection Colby Jack Cheese Cubes
Dairy
Choose Occasionally
Longevity Score
62/100
Food Integrity Score
88/100
Longevity analysis for Private Selection Colby Jack Cheese Cubes Food Integrity analysis for Private Selection Colby Jack Cheese Cubes
Rank 4
Private Selection Mild Cheddar Blend Thick Cut Shredded Cheese
Dairy
Choose Occasionally
Longevity Score
62/100
Food Integrity Score
84/100
Longevity analysis for Private Selection Mild Cheddar Blend Thick Cut Shredded Cheese Food Integrity analysis for Private Selection Mild Cheddar Blend Thick Cut Shredded Cheese
Rank 5
Private Selection Smoked Gouda Cheese Shreds
Dairy
Choose Occasionally
Longevity Score
62/100
Food Integrity Score
80/100
Longevity analysis for Private Selection Smoked Gouda Cheese Shreds Food Integrity analysis for Private Selection Smoked Gouda Cheese Shreds

All analyzed products from Private Selection

19 analyzed products, ranked by balanced score (weaker of Longevity and Food Integrity scores). Plus 5 published products awaiting complete analysis data.

Private Selection Hearts Of Palm In BrineLongevity Score 93/100 · Food Integrity Score 92/100Longevity analysis for Private Selection Hearts Of Palm In Brine · Food Integrity analysis for Private Selection Hearts Of Palm In Brine
Private Selection Wild Caught Mackerel Fillets In Extra Virgin Olive OilLongevity Score 92/100 · Food Integrity Score 92/100Longevity analysis for Private Selection Wild Caught Mackerel Fillets In Extra Virgin Olive Oil · Food Integrity analysis for Private Selection Wild Caught Mackerel Fillets In Extra Virgin Olive Oil
Private Selection Cracked Pepper Hot Smoked Norwegian Atlantic SalmonLongevity Score 88/100 · Food Integrity Score 88/100Longevity analysis for Private Selection Cracked Pepper Hot Smoked Norwegian Atlantic Salmon · Food Integrity analysis for Private Selection Cracked Pepper Hot Smoked Norwegian Atlantic Salmon
Private Selection Succulent & Rich Peeled & Deveined Cooked Giant Tiger PrawnsLongevity Score 88/100 · Food Integrity Score 84/100Longevity analysis for Private Selection Succulent & Rich Peeled & Deveined Cooked Giant Tiger Prawns · Food Integrity analysis for Private Selection Succulent & Rich Peeled & Deveined Cooked Giant Tiger Prawns
Private Selection Pepper Jack Sliced CheeseLongevity Score 78/100 · Food Integrity Score 92/100Longevity analysis for Private Selection Pepper Jack Sliced Cheese · Food Integrity analysis for Private Selection Pepper Jack Sliced Cheese
Private Selection Dark 62% Cacao Chocolate ChunksLongevity Score 78/100 · Food Integrity Score 84/100Longevity analysis for Private Selection Dark 62% Cacao Chocolate Chunks · Food Integrity analysis for Private Selection Dark 62% Cacao Chocolate Chunks
Private Selection Colby Jack Sliced CheeseLongevity Score 72/100 · Food Integrity Score 88/100Longevity analysis for Private Selection Colby Jack Sliced Cheese · Food Integrity analysis for Private Selection Colby Jack Sliced Cheese
Private Selection Peppercorn & Poppy Water CrispsLongevity Score 72/100 · Food Integrity Score 78/100Longevity analysis for Private Selection Peppercorn & Poppy Water Crisps · Food Integrity analysis for Private Selection Peppercorn & Poppy Water Crisps
Private Selection Colby Jack Cheese CubesLongevity Score 62/100 · Food Integrity Score 88/100Longevity analysis for Private Selection Colby Jack Cheese Cubes · Food Integrity analysis for Private Selection Colby Jack Cheese Cubes
Private Selection Mild Cheddar Blend Thick Cut Shredded CheeseLongevity Score 62/100 · Food Integrity Score 84/100Longevity analysis for Private Selection Mild Cheddar Blend Thick Cut Shredded Cheese · Food Integrity analysis for Private Selection Mild Cheddar Blend Thick Cut Shredded Cheese
Private Selection Smoked Gouda Cheese ShredsLongevity Score 62/100 · Food Integrity Score 80/100Longevity analysis for Private Selection Smoked Gouda Cheese Shreds · Food Integrity analysis for Private Selection Smoked Gouda Cheese Shreds
Private Selection Alpine Blend Thick Cut Shredded CheeseLongevity Score 62/100 · Food Integrity Score 74/100Longevity analysis for Private Selection Alpine Blend Thick Cut Shredded Cheese · Food Integrity analysis for Private Selection Alpine Blend Thick Cut Shredded Cheese
Private Selection Sourdough Extra Large Sandwich BunsLongevity Score 62/100 · Food Integrity Score 68/100Longevity analysis for Private Selection Sourdough Extra Large Sandwich Buns · Food Integrity analysis for Private Selection Sourdough Extra Large Sandwich Buns
Private Selection Enriched Rustic White Sliced Wide Pan BreadLongevity Score 52/100 · Food Integrity Score 62/100Longevity analysis for Private Selection Enriched Rustic White Sliced Wide Pan Bread · Food Integrity analysis for Private Selection Enriched Rustic White Sliced Wide Pan Bread
Private Selection Sesame Extra Large Enriched Sandwich RollsLongevity Score 62/100 · Food Integrity Score 52/100Longevity analysis for Private Selection Sesame Extra Large Enriched Sandwich Rolls · Food Integrity analysis for Private Selection Sesame Extra Large Enriched Sandwich Rolls
Private Selection Black Cherry SorbetLongevity Score 42/100 · Food Integrity Score 84/100Longevity analysis for Private Selection Black Cherry Sorbet · Food Integrity analysis for Private Selection Black Cherry Sorbet
Private Selection Smokehouse Deli Sliced Off The Bone HamLongevity Score 42/100 · Food Integrity Score 62/100Longevity analysis for Private Selection Smokehouse Deli Sliced Off The Bone Ham · Food Integrity analysis for Private Selection Smokehouse Deli Sliced Off The Bone Ham
Private Selection Milk Chocolate Sea Salt CaramelsLongevity Score 28/100 · Food Integrity Score 52/100Longevity analysis for Private Selection Milk Chocolate Sea Salt Caramels · Food Integrity analysis for Private Selection Milk Chocolate Sea Salt Caramels
Private Selection White Chocolate ChipsLongevity Score 22/100 · Food Integrity Score 84/100Longevity analysis for Private Selection White Chocolate Chips · Food Integrity analysis for Private Selection White Chocolate Chips

About this dataset

This page represents the 19 Private Selection products currently analyzed and published in Healthy Food Guide. Underlying nutrition and ingredient information comes from the data sources identified on each individual product page.

Rankings include products with sufficient data for the applicable Healthy Food Guide analysis.

Data sources & safety information

Last updated 2026-10-17 (latest verified update across the analyzed Private Selection products).